Okay, maybe a strange question, but what are the benefits of stairs as compared to ramps?
Some thoughts:
-cost effectiveness?
-space saving (slope/length)
-more exercise/less exercise?
Can anybody enlighten me as to other reasons? Because it seems like those reasons are "get around-able" and that having ramps in place of stairs would be really helpful for a lot of people.
The main usefulness is the space, but I wonder how different that is. I guess I should look up what the requirements are for slopes to be easily used by walkers and non-walkers and try to figure out what the difference is. I mean, sure, if you want a direct staircase stairs would be much shorter, but what about ramps with landings? Spiral ramps?
I guess I have a little research to do... anyone want to help?
slope ratio required by ADA 1:12 (one foot of ramp per inch rise)
ceiling height should be at least 7'3''
Okay, so that works out to an 87 foot ramp. Which if it were a straight ramp, it would probably take up more than one room. Of course, ramps could be steeper, but they wouldn't meet the ADA. On the site I found the ADA info, it suggested that home ramps be no steeper than 2:1. This would cut the length down to 43.5 feet. Still pretty long, but if it were done in flights, it might not be as bad.
So lets assume for a minute that ramps for most people ARE doable if we don't meet ADA standards. So, is there a point to making ramps that don't meet ADA standards?
Maybe. Depends on how the ADA makes their standards. If you still needed an ADA ramp, would it make sense to also have ramps for general use. I think so, but I'm going to stop editing for a while while I think about this more.
>>>>>>>
Interior stairs are *best* with a 7'' rise to a 10" tread. So for a 7"3' height (87") you would need 12.5 treads (lets go with 13) which makes 130'' length or about 11 feet.
Okay, so I think that means that a ramp would have to be about 4 times longer than a stair. I bet I could have done this with Pythagorean logic, but whatever.
I wonder how hard it would be to build a house that is one long ramp with rooms coming off at intervals. So this is hard to think about, but I guess the rooms would be built like a staircase. I think I've seen these kinds of buildings. I guess it's like a step pyramid. I wish I were better a visualizing things. I guess I need to go play with some blocks! Good thing I have a 2 year old nephew and a 2 year old cousin!